Is getting a degree at Harvard Medical school a waste of money, does it matter where you go to medical school?

I am planning to apply to 13 different medical schools, among them are Harvard and Columbia, but does it really matter where a doctor goes to medical school? Would I really be heads above other people when applying for positions with a degree from an Ivy League school?

Responses:

The people who go to the better medical schools have a better chance at getting the internships and residencies that they want. That allows them to earn more in the future, and also to practice the area of medicine that they want. So - yes, it does make a difference
Of course it does. To be a local GP down the road with a family practice - probably not. To snag a top research position at John Hopkins - you bet. Thanks Bill
Not necessarily. It is not quite so simple. First it depends on what residency you want to do - some residencies do not even match full. It also depends on what kind of doctor you want to be. A top researcher probably would benefit from Harvard, but the vast majority of physicians would do just fine at any other number of medical schools many many are very good & certainly cost a lot less. When you look at the number of residencies & consider the size of the Harvard cl, obviously there are more residencies than that; so a top med student in many med schools have the possibility of matching to their first or second choice residency. Once you enter practice; it may be nice to say you went to Harvard; but you will still make a good living & be in demand as long as you are a good doc. So, its something you can only answer for yourself. can you foot the bill comfortably as well? That's a major consideration to not be taken lightly. One of the top ER residencies in the country is LAC USC; and there were no Harvard graduates in it for the 3 years I was there. So it really does depend on a number of factors. Good luck
It very much matters where you go to medical school. Most physicians do reasonably well, but all else being equal, the graduate of a prestigious medical school would certainly be the one chosen, especially when it comes to desired residencies
All medical schools are created equal and that equality is ured by the National Board of Medical Examiners and the accrediting authority, the Liaison Committee on Medical Education. People who allege one medical school is better than another, based on the education provided, are wrong. If any medical school was inferior to another it would lose its accreditation or, stated another way, no medical school is permitted to graduate a majority of "C" students while other schools graduate a majority of "A" students. All medical schools are required to administer the NBME's Shelf Exams at the end of each cl. These exams are scored by the NBME, not the schools. If Harvard produced superior results to the Medical College of Georgia, do you think that MCG would not adopt Harvard's curriculum or that MCG would be continued to be allowed to produce inferior doctors? Would you accept that a Volkswagen was the best car based on 5 people saying that it was the best car? Would your opinion change if all 5 worked for Volkswagen? Many people respond to questions about "the best medical schools" and cite the US News and World Report's annual article about medical school rankings. They do not have a clue how the magazine made those determinations. In the most recent published rankings list there were as little as five respondents and those were all medical school college Deans. Hardly a statistically valid sampling, would not you agree? Why were there so few respondents? Because the ociation of American Medical Colleges objects to the criteria used and the method of sampling, so the majority of medical schools refuse to participate. If you're going to become a physician you need to know the source of any data you're going to rely on or prove it yourself - and in this case, the information is readily available on the Internet - all you have to do is Google it. To correct some other misinformation - all medical schools have to have research opportunities available for medical students it's an accreditation requirement. At primary care oriented schools the research is an option. At research oriented medical schools it is mandatory and the focus for the students is not the research itself but the proper scientific method for conducting and reporting how research is done. The research is done by both instructors that's one of the carrots used to attract top research scientists to teach at medical schools and paid researchers. In addition, most medical researchers have advanced science degrees, not just the MD. So why do the Harvards and Johns Hopkins of the world have reputations as being "the best"? It's a three part answer. First, the "best" known names have earned their reputations on the quality of the residency programs provided and residency programs have nothing to do with a medical school, the quality, number and types of research conducted again, nothing to do with the medical school itself and the medical centers ociated with each program. Secondly, the history of the Ivy League schools arises from over a century ago when only the wealthy could afford to go to college. As the economy changed and more of the 'common' people could afford college, the "Ivy League" schools raised their tuition to keep out the riff - raff, thus maintaining their standard of catering to society's elite cl. But many of the programs at Ivy League schools do produce superior graduates. The MBA programs at Harvard and Wharton are the 'Gold" standard in business. The law programs at Princeton and Yale are also "Gold' standards. the same for engineering, physics, etc, but not medicine. Medicine is the only specialty that has a quality urance governing authority. Third, reputations are really marketing's sleight of hand. For example, the National Insitute of Health is the other often - cited ranking system for medical schools. However, this 'ranking' is based on the amount of research dollars given to each school, which, again, has nothing to do with the quality of the education provided at a school. But that doesn't stop some schools from claiming "We're # X according to the NIH". So, to answer your question in a different way, would you be heads above other people with a degree from an Ivy League school? Maybe to the naive. But the medical community only cares where you did your residency, as that denotes the quality of your education. You can spend $50, 000 / semester at an Ivy League school or less than $20, 000 / semester at your own state's university medical school and both will get you to your MD. The name of the school on your diploma doesn't get you into the better residency programs. What does get you in are the scores you obtain on the USMLE exams and the quality of the reviews you received during your clinical rotations. One last little poke in the ribs - UCLA came to the University of Maryland to copy UM's Emergency Medicine residency program and that's why the University

Tags: inferior, governing, catering, criteria, allege

Follow this dicussion..

Related Images:

Knowledge Base

Can I maintain 2 different medical insurance plans?

i have retired and am covered by my retirement plan, however i have taken a new job in a different state and they are offering me medical coverage as well. can i keep both coverages? my daughter is still in ny until she finishes school and i am currently in (medical insurance)

Medical insurance?

i need to put my fiance on my medical bc i really think he needs to see a doctor soon. but for the good insurance it would be 120 every paycheck. i live paycheck to paycheck now so that would be very hard. this one insurance offered is 70 bucks (medical program)

medical insurance?

i am looking to obtain a medical insurance policy. any insurance brokers out there want to quote me? i am 21 years old. i have excellent health. 6 foot 160 llbs. 92630 zip code. california. i am self employed. my job offers it. the best way to get medical insurance (medical insurance)

Related Images:

Knowledge Base: Medical Insurance

medical insurance?

Medical School?

as for my concern of about medical school. i would like to know a few things about it. how many years of studies is medical school ? do you have to get a degree in medicine prior getting into medical school ? how much will medical school cost ? is (medical school)

Medical Insurance?

my gf's medical insurance is about to run out. is it possible for me to get her covered under my medical insurance. unless you're married, i do not think that is possible. talk to your insurance agency about it. generally not, unless she becomes your spouse legally. sure, just marry (medical program)

Any Low cost health and medical insurance plans for young adults?

hi. i am 19 and in college and employed. i missed the deadline to sign up for health insurance with my employer, and now im searching several health and medical insurance plans that are affordable to my income. please if anybody know any low cost and affordable health and insurance (medical software)

Can I maintain 2 different medical insurance plans?

Related Images:

Knowledge Base: Medical School

How would medical school look at retakes?

i am planning on applying to medical school sometime in the next year or two, but i am retaking at least three cl es. i am wondering how would those retakes impact my application? has anyone been through this situation?. it's not going to look good. medical schools look at (medical school)

Should a medical school be responsible to provide transport to hospitals for medical studies?Why?

medical studies are conducted in hospitals during 3rd year of medical studies. i have a friend who is trying very hard to get her medical school to provide the university's own bus transport from the university's hostel to the hospital. the university's management has refused to do so. but next (medical school)

How does medical school work in the united states?

if you graduate high school at 18 and go straight to college how old will you be when you become a first year intern? do you go straight to medical school after high school? or do you have to do another course / major and then medical school? thanks so (medical school)

Is getting a degree at Harvard Medical school a waste of money, does it matter where you go to medical school?

i am planning to apply to 13 different medical schools, among them are harvard and columbia, but does it really matter where a doctor goes to medical school? would i really be heads above other people when applying for positions with a degree from an ivy league school?. of course (medical school)

Medical School?